You get yourself into a terrible situation and end up killing a man in a fight. No one knows what you’ve done, and you retreat to your parents’ house to try and figure out what to do. In your old room, you absentmindedly pick up a stack of baseball cards until one stops you in your tracks—the man you just killed is in the stands behind home plate, and he’s pointing at you.

scary woman with bonnet in graveyard

Want more writing prompts like this one? Leave your email address below to get instant access to your PDF copy of "51 Terrifying Writing Prompts."

Thank you for reading The Moonlighting Writer. Click here to download your free PDF copy of "51 Terrifying Writing Prompts."

Share This